It instantly prompted a debate with some figures within the SNP, together with the MP Joanna Cherry, demanding that the Scottish Authorities implement the recommendation within the NHS in Scotland, whereas the Scottish Greens MSP Maggie Chapman, mentioned her occasion would oppose any strikes to lift the age that such medicine might be prescribed on the NHS.
In a letter to Dr Gregor Smith, the chief medical officer, Ms Cherry mentioned: “The prescription of puberty blockers locations gender questioning youngsters and younger folks on a medicalised pathway which has life-long implications. The NHS in Scotland has been sluggish to react to rising proof of the hurt of those practices and all too usually depends on worldwide greatest follow as a catch all to keep away from tough conversations.”
READ MORE: Cass Evaluation, transgender clinics, and a ‘poisonous’ debate
She added: “The publication of the Cass Evaluation must be an pressing wake-up name that companies for youngsters and younger folks have to be urgently re-designed and puberty blockers faraway from use in Scotland.”
However writing on X, previously Twitter, Ms Chapman, the Scottish Greens equalities spokeswoman, famous: “A brief, preliminary response to the Cass Report.
“Trans Healthcare is important to defending and supporting the rights and lives of trans folks. Scottish Greens will oppose any strikes to extend the age of accessing gender affirming care to 25.
READ MORE: Fergus Ewing: We should finish Bute Home deal earlier than election
“Trans rights are human rights. We should guarantee trans individuals are in a position to entry the care they want in a well timed & compassionate method. It’s clear that gender affirming care performs a significant function in supporting & defending trans folks …We might oppose any strikes to extend the minimal age to 25 to obtain such care.”
For its half the Scottish Authorities has not but mentioned the way it will reply saying final week it was within the strategy of contemplating the Cass Evaluation’s findings.
However some on the SNP backbenches are getting twitchy.
The problem of younger folks, gender self-identification and the function of drugs within the course of or not was on the coronary heart of the Scottish Authorities’s most internally contested reforms.
The now shelved gender recognition reform invoice included the proposal to decrease the age from 18 to 16 to permit somebody to use for a gender certificates and to take away the necessity for a physician to approve the applying.
It precipitated the largest ever SNP backbench insurrection with 9 MSPs failing to again the federal government’s laws when it was voted on in Holyrood at its first key parliamentary stage again in October 2022.
Some observers consider the difficulty of gender self-identification and the separate row of transwomen prisoners being held in ladies’s prisons – which got here to a head with the Isla Bryson double rape case – contributed to the demise of Nicola Sturgeon as SNP chief and First Minister.
Mr Yousaf should tread very rigorously if he’s to keep away from reawakening these SNP backbench tensions.
Over the weekend, it was reported that his response to the Cass report may very well be “pivotal” in whether or not this group of SNP MSPs spark a insurrection over the management’s co-operation with the Scottish Greens, who’re sturdy supporters of gender self-identification.
One SNP MSP advised Scotland on Sunday that “the response to the Cass report could also be pivotal”, with backbenchers trying “to what extent the SNP will try to appease the Greens slightly than act in the perfect pursuits of Scottish youngsters”.
Any backbench insurrection would come at a tough time for the First Minister whose authorities has confronted a sequence of great issues over the previous yr, together with a backlash towards its Hate Crime Act, additional turmoil amid extra delays to already late and over-budget ferries, a difficult price range that included tax rises and public service cuts and questions over how ministers carried out enterprise through the pandemic.
Individually, a police investigation into the SNP’s funds that resulted in Ms Sturgeon being arrested, questioned and launched with out cost has hung over the occasion of presidency.
The query on the minds of many observers would inevitably be ‘would Mr Yousaf’s management survive a brand new full blown insurrection forward of an election?
With the stakes so excessive for the First Minister, his silence so far on the Cass evaluate is due to this fact not shocking.
However with Ms Cherry demanding a swift reply to her name for a ban on puberty blockers for beneath 18s, it is not a matter that is going to fade from public consideration within the coming weeks.
Get Unspun delivered direct to your inbox each weekday night by signing up right here.
